Senior Member
Join Date: Dec 2010
Posts: 468
|
Well, we should probably remember that our good friend kbs just underwent serious surgery and might not quite be himself right now.
Kbs, I hope you are doing well, and forgive us if we are grousing about your behavior if it is drug-induced. I hope you heal well and quickly. |
#11 |
Senior Member
Join Date: Dec 2013
Posts: 798
|
Quote:
Who? What? Where? :P Really ridiculous that rules cannot be protected. At least for some time they should have an exclusive like in pharma industry and other process where the first inventor invested much more time / money to develop the idea, than the copycats. Join the (unofficial) Realm-Works IRC Chat: #realm-works on the Rizon Network (https://wiki.rizon.net/index.php?title=Servers) -> Browser Client: https://kiwiirc.com/client/irc.rizon.net |
|
#12 |
Senior Member
Join Date: Mar 2013
Location: Greater London, UK
Posts: 2,623
|
I think the general issue with game rules is that most games are a mix of little bits from lots of other games. Pretty much nothing is truly original. Probably the only copyright/trademark/patent could relate to a particular combination of lots of little bits.
Farling Author of the Realm Works Import tool, Realm Works Output tool and Realm Works to Foundry module Donations gratefully received via Patreon, Ko-Fi or Paypal |
#13 |
Senior Member
Join Date: Oct 2016
Posts: 621
|
Rules can definitely be protected, it is Mechanics that can't be. Hasbro definitely could protect the rules of D&D but they couldn't stop you from making a game that used the same six attributes (Strength, Dexterity, etc). They could prevent you from calling it anything to do with Dungeons and Dragons, or even from probably naming it Dungeons and Demons, as an obvious derivative, but the basic mechanics such as spellcasting and attacking cannot be prevented
|
#14 |
Senior Member
Join Date: Jul 2012
Location: Texas
Posts: 707
|
Quote:
Tunnels & Trolls in late 70s was first that came to my mind and was attacked by then TSR, and later again by WOC in 2005. Gygax Magazine (yea that Gygax) was a periodical in similar form to Dragon Magazine and again was attacked via WOC/Hazbro, and again tossed as not related to the IP they held over World of Greyhawk (something I keep up with in detail). And after personally speaking with Luke Gygax on this, the basis of claim ironically was the very name itself. The court ruled that a man has the right to his own name was the basis of dismissal. Unfortunately in this particular case, it ended up quagmired in an internal family battle and died. And lastly... Mazes & Monsters, which by any standard was a blatant aim at D&D... and any growing up in the late 70s / early 80s will tell you an impact on the game... but again tossed not once but twice since they (as you note in your post above) were not RPGs but a Novel & made for TV Movie.... The follow up book "The Dungeon Master" couldn't get any bolder at "re-use" of a name... And while WOC could continue filing suits... at some point they reach the law of diminishing return... I suppose.... DLG D&D> Pre 1e White Box Edition, 1e, 2e, 3.5 Currently, Set in the World of Greyhawk (The first, longest running and Best Campaign Setting) Software>Extensive use of all forms of MS Products, Visual Studio 2012, DAZ 3d, AutoCAD, Adobe Products. Gaming Specific>Campaign Cartographer, D20 Pro Alpha & BattleGrounds Beta Tester, World Builder, Dungeon Crafter, LWD Hero Lab, Realm Works, Inkwell Ideas Citybuilder & Dungeon Builder, Auto-Realm, Dundjinni Contributing Writer for TSR, WOC, & Canonfire |
|
#15 |
Senior Member
Join Date: Oct 2016
Posts: 621
|
Ok, I sit corrected and educated :-). I agree that it is mostly a waste of time and resources to pursue these things for 99% of offenders, but WotC ARE notoriously bad for going after copyright infringement.
|
#16 |
Senior Member
Join Date: Jul 2012
Location: Texas
Posts: 707
|
Quote:
I have a friend (shameless Plug for Casey below) that published some work they did as a collective on The World of Greyhawk- Bandit Kingdoms... and they went after him... Now understand, he was a non-paid lead member of what was called the "triad" back in what was termed "Living-Greyhawk" in the early 2000's. And all he did was assemble the work many did under one binded book so to speak. He credited them, and basically the cost to print was a wash vs profit, but WOC filed anyway... after 3 different meetings through arbitration, they finally pulled the suit.... Ironically the only ones that would use the perioditcal would be Greyhawk users, which facilitates WOC and their IP and product.... They were just butt hurt that he was able to assemble the various originating authors when they couldn't. But in this lawsuit happy world we live in, you can sue anyone for anything .... logic and reason to be determined later... *snark* For all you Greyhawkers following along.... >Casey's Work>http://www.drivethrurpg.com/product/...ngdoms-Summary D&D> Pre 1e White Box Edition, 1e, 2e, 3.5 Currently, Set in the World of Greyhawk (The first, longest running and Best Campaign Setting) Software>Extensive use of all forms of MS Products, Visual Studio 2012, DAZ 3d, AutoCAD, Adobe Products. Gaming Specific>Campaign Cartographer, D20 Pro Alpha & BattleGrounds Beta Tester, World Builder, Dungeon Crafter, LWD Hero Lab, Realm Works, Inkwell Ideas Citybuilder & Dungeon Builder, Auto-Realm, Dundjinni Contributing Writer for TSR, WOC, & Canonfire |
|
#17 |
Senior Member
Join Date: Oct 2014
Location: Chicago, IL
Posts: 1,690
|
Quote:
my Realm Works videos https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCZU...4DwXXkvmBXQ9Yw |
|
#18 |
Senior Member
Join Date: Jul 2012
Location: Texas
Posts: 707
|
Quote:
My beloved Greyhawk suffers a similar fate at the hand of Hazbro by proxy to Lorraine's shortsightedness.. even when a group of us tried to outright purchase the IP..... they would rather let it sit collecting dust and cannibalizing its corpse by repurposing pieces and shoe-horning them into Forgotten Realms where they NEVER WHERE...... huff huff..GURRREE HOWLLLLL. now you did it KB... you inadvertently awoke the beast known as the disdain of Lorraine and WOC... MAWAAHHAAAHAHA... Back... Back in the cage of despair you beast!.... The only words I would say are certainly not fit for the "younglings here" hehe BJ would be sending me a nasty note even though I'd be right..... Suffice to say... In the interests of trying to be the only company to offer RGP... they forgot the endproduct user will have the last say... And now all these years Later, My friends Eric Mona, Wolfgang Baur, Monty Cook, Gary Holan, Anna Meyer and many others are being recognized as industry leaders in spite of the past (and present) shortsighted bureaucracy. Why, because they listened to the people who use the products. DLG D&D> Pre 1e White Box Edition, 1e, 2e, 3.5 Currently, Set in the World of Greyhawk (The first, longest running and Best Campaign Setting) Software>Extensive use of all forms of MS Products, Visual Studio 2012, DAZ 3d, AutoCAD, Adobe Products. Gaming Specific>Campaign Cartographer, D20 Pro Alpha & BattleGrounds Beta Tester, World Builder, Dungeon Crafter, LWD Hero Lab, Realm Works, Inkwell Ideas Citybuilder & Dungeon Builder, Auto-Realm, Dundjinni Contributing Writer for TSR, WOC, & Canonfire |
|
#19 |
Senior Member
Join Date: Jul 2012
Location: Texas
Posts: 707
|
So to get the thread Semi- back on track... for any looking for back history of the original works of MANY of the "NEW" forgotten Realms published materials (and many more "Stolen" pieces to come) one only has to look as far as The World of Greyhawk.... and change the names to protect the ignorant.... because WOC/Hazbro hopes you don't notice the regurgitation...
DLG D&D> Pre 1e White Box Edition, 1e, 2e, 3.5 Currently, Set in the World of Greyhawk (The first, longest running and Best Campaign Setting) Software>Extensive use of all forms of MS Products, Visual Studio 2012, DAZ 3d, AutoCAD, Adobe Products. Gaming Specific>Campaign Cartographer, D20 Pro Alpha & BattleGrounds Beta Tester, World Builder, Dungeon Crafter, LWD Hero Lab, Realm Works, Inkwell Ideas Citybuilder & Dungeon Builder, Auto-Realm, Dundjinni Contributing Writer for TSR, WOC, & Canonfire |
#20 |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|